MIDI Foot Controller Comparison Guide

If you’re looking to get hands-free and do some quick manipulation of your sound, MIDI foot controllers are the way to go.

Foot controllers allow you to modify your gear into the more expensive, foot-controlled version (e.g., Boss RC-30 into RC-300, RC-202 into RC-505, or HX Stomp into Helix LT).

If you’ve been on the search you know that there are many foot controllers out there. And it can be a confusing purchase (particularly if you’re new to the world of MIDI).

But don’t fret, we’ll cover all you need to know to make an intelligent investment.

We also compare some of the top foot controllers. Our table has everything laid out neatly so you can decide on the best one for your needs.

Study this guide, watch the tutorials, and you’ll know what you need to make a sound investment.

What Does a MIDI Foot Controller Do?

A MIDI foot controller (also called a footswitch or foot pedal) allows you to control your music hardware (e.g., effects pedals) and software with the press of a button.

So you can use your feet to turn things on and off, make them louder, or select presets.

A foot controller sends and receives MIDI messages, which is a kind of universal language shared among a lot of music gear.

What is MIDI?

MIDI stands for Musical Instrument Digital Interface. It sends codes that can be translated into any number of functions.

There are different types of MIDI. For example:

  • Control Channel: sends messages like turn on/off or gradually increase
  • Note: each note has a MIDI number assigned to it
  • Program Change: select the next or previous program or bank

MIDI codes can be assigned to trigger certain functions on an effects pedal (like HX Stomp), amp (like Line6), or DAW (like Ableton or Logic). This process of assigning is called “mapping.”

You can map a certain MIDI signal to turn the record button on and off in Ableton, for example. Or you can map an expression pedal to control your main volume or the level of distortion.

Why use a MIDI Footswitch?

If you’re playing live or need your hands free to play your instrument, being able to MIDI map to footswitches is a lifesaver.

Musicians use MIDI foot controllers for many functions, including:

  • Turn recording on and off and control levels with your feet in Ableton or Logic
  • Select your song, preset, or batch with a Helix multi-effects box
  • Play a bass line or drumbeat live using your feet
  • As a sustain pedal on a keyboard
  • Tap tempo or turn click track on/off
  • Control your keyboard, guitar, drum track, and EQ all from one space
  • Saving space and money: often the big difference in more expensive versions of pedals is the presence of footswitches.
    One foot controller can control many pedals: that means you save space and money.

MIDI Foot Controller Comparison Chart

Below is a list of the most popular foot controllers below $350/€340. The chart goes in increasing order of cost.

Harley Benton MP-100 / Meloaudio Midi ControllerBehringer FCB1010Nektar PacerSingular Sound Midi Maestro ControllerXsonic AirstepMorningstar MC8Keith McMillen SoftStep 2
Message TypesCC and Prog ChangeCC; Note; Prog Change; Tap; more through hacksallCC, PC, PB, Note On/Offallall, including press, release, long pressall
Number of Programmable Switches10101065810
Expression Pedals or Inputs2 inputs2 pedals2 inputs1 input2 inputs4 inputs10 (all switches have expression capacity)
Additional footswitch inputs024 inputs (2×2)15 adding additional Lite pedal120
Customizable LEDs and/or Pedal Screennono5-character LED, colored LED per switch; Track and Transport iconsScreen per switchno1 screen with dedicated slot per switch4-character LED
Presets 10100 (10 Banks, 10 Presets)24 user configurable presets; 2 read-only for DAW60 (10 banks of 6 presets)5 without use of app (practically unlimited on app)660 (30 banks, 22 Presets)16
Software editor?no 3rd party 3rd partyyes; mobile appyes; mobile appyesyes
USB powered?yesno USByesno USByes; and rechargeableyesyes
Simultaneous commands15 program changes & 2 MIDI messages per preset16 MIDI commands6 MIDI commands8 MIDI commands16 MIDI commands per switch6 MIDI commands per switch
Bluetoothnononoyesyesnono
Special FeaturesCheap and gets most jobs doneCheap; Built-in expression pedals.Sturdy; colored LEDs; MMC and Mackie MCU-supportProgramming via app over Blutooth; individual screensFull wireless capabilitiesOmniports; large screenEach switch is expression pedal and arrow keys
Manual linklinklinklinklinklinklinklink
Comparison of the leading MIDI foot controllers

Quick rundown of the controllers

Let’s unpack that table above, then look at each of the pedals individually.

You can get a good MIDI foot controller for as little as $100. They can have basic messages for turning pedals on and off and changing batches/presets.

The Pacer and MC6 (not reviewed above but the smaller version of MC8) are wonderful all arounders, but quite different. MC6 has more features, and the Pacer is good for DAWs and being pounded.

MC8 and SoftStep2 are similarly priced and give you options galore without a headache. But they are very different pedals.

As you’ll see, the size of controllers can vary greatly: from the Morningstar to the Behringer FCB 1010 at 27″.

Harley Benton MP-100 / MelAudio MIDI Commander

If you’re looking for simple on/off and program change functions, the MP-100/Commander is reliable, sturdy, and cheap.

(Note: Harley Benton’s MP-100 and the MelAudio MIDI Commander offer the same functions and so are considered together.)

From Thomann or Amazon

These controllers have some presets for easy integration with Kemper and Ax FX among other amps, and can also be customized to work with anything that takes MIDI Control Change and Program Change messages.

For guitarists, that might do the job just fine. If you’re looking to turn switches on and off and don’t mind programming by hand, this box will do the job.

Specs

  • 10 Programmable foot-switches
  • 2 Expression Pedal Inputs for Volume, Wah or other effect parameters (Expression pedals are not included)
  • Sends Program Change & Control Change Midi commands via the USB port as well as via the MIDI output
  • Already contains preprogrammed configurations for popular software or devices, e.g. Bias FX, JamUp, Kemper or Ax FX
  • 2 Expression Pedal Inputs: 6.3 mm Stereo jack
  • MIDI out
  • USB
  • Powered by 2x AAA batteries or AAA batteries (not included)
  • Built-in charging function for batteries
  • Dimensions (W x D x H): 286 x 110 x 65 mm
  • Weight: 950 g
  • Includes MIDI cable and USB Type B cable

(Specs from Thomann)

Pros:

  • Simple, clear functions
  • Inexpensive
  • Well-built

Cons:

  • Limited functions
  • Limited visual support
  • No software editor

Here’s an overview of the MeloAudio MIDI Commander (again, basically the same as the MP-11). As you’ll see, for some applications it can do all you need for a cheap price.

From Thomann or Amazon

Behringer FCB1010

Built like a tank – but slightly smaller – the FCB1010 foot controller has worshiped beneath the feet of many a musician.

Available from Thomann or Amazon

The FCB1010 is “modelled” on (or rips off) the Roland FC-300, and is a fraction of the cost.

Places your FCB1010 won’t be welcome

Cheap never goes out of style, but girth does. This is a monster (wider than a big TV), and your bandmates might not take kindly to your taking valuable stage floor real estate.

If you don’t mind getting a little dirty, there are unofficial (UNO) firmware updates, chips, and general hacks for the FCB1010 to get it to do most anything.

Due to the size, the FCB1010 doesn’t get tons of love, but with the UNO hacks it can be a very inexpensive solution to your foot switching needs.

Specs

  • MIDI Foot Controller with two expression pedals and MIDI merge function
  • 10 banks with 10 presets (editable); presets for BEHRINGER amps included
  • Two expression pedals
  • Controller number and range: freely configurable in MIDI Channel
  • Simultaneous transmission of five MIDI program changes and two MIDI controllers per preset
  • MIDI note command for trigger and tap-tempo applications
  • Two programmable galvanically uncoupled switching sockets e.g. for the channel switching of a guitar amplifier
  • MIDI merge function allows soft through and mixing of controller and input data
  • Built-in power adapter
  • Weight: 3.5 kg
  • Dimensions (W x H x D): 687 x 60 x 221 mm / 27″ x 2.4″ x 8.7″

(Specs from Thomann)

Pros:

  • Spacious board; 2 built-in expression pedals
  • Good online community
  • Limited immediate integration with other hardware

Cons:

  • Big and heavy
  • May require some hacking to get it to do what you want
  • Limited visual support

Roll up your sleeves if you want to manually program this baby! Here’s a tutorial to walk (crawl?) you through the process.

Available from Thomann or Amazon

Nektar Pacer

With the Pacer, we jump ahead in terms of options, ergonomics, visual feedback, and general sleekness.

Available at Thomann or Amazon

Nektar took their keyboard experience to the ground with the Pacer. At its price bracket, it doesn’t have a clear competitor.

Pacer is sturdy, easy to read, and can be programmed to do most anything you want (unless you’re super technical).

Users of supported DAWS will find the toe’s access to your track and transports functions to be a dream come true.

Unfortunately, this integration doesn’t extend to Ableton (although we’ve conceived of some good workarounds). Nektar has not come out with an updated firmware in years, leaving you with an excellent piece of hardware with no ongoing support.

Specs

  • Robust metal housing
  • Track and transport control with Nektar DAW integration
  • Support for e.g. Bitwig, Cubase, GarageBand, Logic, Nuendo, Reason, Reaper and Studio One
  • MCU for all common DAWs and Pro Tools Setup
  • Fully programmable MIDI controller
  • 24 Presets – banks A-D per memory 6 presets
  • Up to 16 MIDI commands can be sent per Preset
  • 10 Programmable footswitches
  • 4 Programmable external footswitches (optional)
  • 2 Programmable external expression pedals (optional)
  • 4 Programmable relays
  • 1 Programmable encoders
  • The footswitches can be programmed to send up to 6 commands when activated or in sequence (one after the other)
  • RGB LEDs offer multicolor status displays (freely programmable)
  • Dedicated icons for Nektar DAW integration
  • MIDI Machine Control (MMC)
  • MIDI output for external hardware control or for use as USB-MIDI interface
  • USB Class Compliant (no driver needed)
  • Powered by USB host or USB power adapter
  • Connection for external 9 V power supply (middle negative)
  • Presets for popular guitar MIDI devices such as Line6 Pod and Helix, Avid Eleven, Kemper Profiler and AxefX
  • MAC (OS X 10.5 or higher) and PC (Windows XP, Vista, 7, 8, 10 or higher) and Linux (Ubuntu)
  • Nektar DAW integration on Windows Vista, 7, 8, 10 and Mac OS X 10.7 or higher

(Specs from Thomann)

Pros:

  • Versatile controller and well-built
  • Great presets/patches for many DAWs, amps, and effects pedals
  • Quiet, comfortable pedals
  • Decent 3rd party editor
  • Clear LEDs and plenty of space make it a good choice for live gigs
  • Excellent value

Cons:

  • Poor support: no firmware update or Ableton integration
  • Not as many commands per pedal as Morningstar or SoftStep (if your needs are very technical)

Here’s our tutorial on using the 3rd party software editor.

Pacer’s full manual

http://support.nektartech.com/Support/pacer-support/Creating-and-Customizing-Presets-for-Pacer

From Thomann or Amazon

Morningstar MC8

With an easy to read screen, incredibly versatile omniports, and a great software editor and online community, Morningstar’s MC8 has become the darling of many musicians.

Morningstar MC8 (image source: Morningstar)

Specs

Features

30 dual-paged Banks of 8 switches
Quickly access 16 presets per bank by toggling page. That’s 480 preset slots to store anything you need.

Omniports
4 x 1/4 inch ports that can be individually set as MIDI outputs, Aux switch inputs or Expression pedal inputs.

Large LCD Display
Interactive real-time visual feedback on important information such as current bank, active preset and expression pedal position. All designed to help you perform better.


Simultaneous MIDI Control

Send up to 16 different MIDI messages with a single switch press. Control up to 16 different MIDI devices via 16 unique selectable MIDI channels.

Name your Switches and Banks

All switches and banks can be named so you always know exactly what they do.

User Selectable MIDI Message Types

Select from more than 20 MIDI message types and functions including PC, CC, Note, SysEx, MIDI Clock and many more.

Built-in MIDI Clock

Sync all your time-based effects via tap tempo or pre-set tempo with the built-in MIDI Clock function on the MC8. Eliminates the need for a separate MIDI clock device.
Action-Based Control
Send different messages with the same switch depending on what action you perform on it – Press, Release, Double Tap, Long Press and more

USB Class Compliant MIDI

Control any of your favourite DAWs and music software. Compatible with Windows, OSX and iOS.

Desktop Editor
Downloadable or Chrome browser-accessible editor allows you to program and name your switches and banks quickly and easily.

Technical Specifications

Enclosure Dimensions:224mm x 125mm x 50mm
Powered by (any of the following):9-12V DC Center Negative (min 250mA)
USB Power
9-12V AC/DC MIDI Phantom Power via MIDI pins 6 & 7
Hardware:Angled anodized aluminium enclosure
8 x Soft Touch switches
40 x 4 character LCD Screen
Connections I/O:4 x Omniports (MIDI output, expression pedal input or aux switch input)
1 x DC power input
1 x USB Type B; carries buss power and MIDI (class compliant)
1 x 7-pin MIDI Out/Thru; carries phantom power via pins 6 & 7
1 x 7-pin MIDI In; carries phantom power via pins 6 & 7

Pros:

  • Excellent design: compact with enormous options
  • Great community and customer support
  • Great integration with Helix, Line6, etc

Cons:

  • Screen may be too small for some gigs/players
  • Buttons are too close for comfort for fast live work
Morningstar MC8 (image source: Morningstar)

Nektar Pacer vs Morningstar MC8

In many ways, the Pacer and MC8 are winners to our ears and eyes, particularly from the guitarist’s/bassist’s point of view.

Although they have specific strengths and weaknesses, the MC8 (or even the cheaper MC6) comes out stronger in many ways.

So, even though you’ll pay more for it, here are some advantages of the MC8 over Pacer:

  • 4 Omniports (MIDI outputs, Aux switch inputs, or Expression pedal inputs)
  • Phantom powered and can phantom power
  • More storage for presets
  • More versatile: can send more specific MIDI messages and special functions (e.g., double tap)
  • Great user community and actual customer support

For those reasons, MC8 just might be a winner at the $350 and below bracket.

But there are still definite qualities that the Pacer has over the MC8, and these shine in specific situations:

  • Musicians using DAWs and Amp Patches: if you’re using one of their supported DAWs or apps (e.g., Logic, GarageBand, or Mainstage), you get instant mapping for Transport and Track controls, and it is wonderful. These are always a click away in any preset, which is perfect if you perform through/with your DAW.
    Also great factory presets for Helix, Line6, etc.
  • Live, thrashy musicians: if you need to smash the right pedal fast and don’t want to worry about hitting the wrong one, that’s a good reason to consider the Pacer. Even if you’re wearing boots, there’s plenty of room.
    That big screen on the MC8 would also be an expensive repair if it got cracked.
  • Quiet, non-thrashy musicians: Pacer’s pedals feel great and they are incredibly quiet. No clicking, but the input is clear.
  • Visual ease: Pacer’s LED’s lights are incredibly easy to see. In the Transport and Track settings, you get icons showing you what you’re doing, which is great. Otherwise, you can pick your LED color, and they toggle between dim and bright.

So, we don’t want to tell you what to buy, but advantages of the Pacer are quick integration with some DAWs as well as space and clarity for on-the-fly stomping.

Morningstar’s entire lineup has more options with a great, easy-to-use editor and community.

Xsonic Airstep Smart Controller

The newest kid on the block is Xsonic’s Airstep. Its big boasts are wireless control and quick programming and integration through its mobile app.

Available from Thomann

Airstep is a dream-come-true for musicians who’ve been wanting a wireless MIDI foot controller and who don’t mind needing access to their phone or tablet during a performance.

For the rest of us, Airstep has some strikes against it. It has very little visual feedback on the unit itself, so it’s easy to get lost among your presets. It also only has five switches, and you’re encouraged to buy the Airstep light for another five.

In truth, if your entire rig is not wireless, having a wireless foot controller does little for you. With very little on-board (only 5 sets of presets can be stored on the unit itself, no text LEDs), you’re left at the mercy of your phone and Bluetooth connection.

Specs

  • Wireless
  • Controls and switches effects pedals, hardware effects and amplifiers with MIDI input or relay footswitch input as well as DAW programs and apps on the mobile phone, tablet or computer with Bluetooth or USB
  • Integrated battery offers up to 300 hours of wireless operation between charges
  • Sends all kinds of MIDI messages (via 5-pin MIDI, USB or Bluetooth), HID messages (Bluetooth) or classic foot switch commands
  • Sends up to 8 different commands with one push of a button
  • 3 Selectable switching options (press, release, long press) to send different commands
  • 5 Programmable foot switches
  • Expression pedal input supports TRS and RTS types
  • Intuitive smartphone app for editing all settings
  • 30 m Range for wireless communication
  • Power on / off switch
  • The battery can be charged with a 9V DC power supply unit (not included) or with the included USB barrel connector adapter charging cable
  • Robust aluminium housing
  • System requirements: iOS 10 and higher, Mac OS X 10.6 and higher, Android 4.0 and higher, Windows 10
  • Dimensions (L x W x H): 300 x 70 x 45 mm
  • Weight: 700 g
  • Includes USB-C OTG adapter, USB barrel connector adapter charging cable and USB cable (A-B)

Connections:

  • 2 x Input for expression pedals: 6.3 mm stereo jack
  • 2 x Output for relay foot switch: 6.3 mm stereo jack
  • 1 x MIDI input: 5-pin
  • 2 x MIDI output: 5-pin
  • 1 x USB Type-C connection
  • Power supply connection: 2.1 mm x 5.5 mm barrel connector, polarity (-) inside

Note: Register your product at www.w-distribution.de/Warranty and extend the guarantee to 4 years.

Pros:

  • Wireless with Bluetooth capacity
  • Relatively inexpensive
  • Promises a large number of presets customized for different gear
  • 2 MIDI outs

Cons:

  • Over-dependence on app for live gigs
  • Very limited visual feedback if away from the app
  • Only 5 switches without Lite extension
Available from Thomann

Singular Sound Midi Maestro Controller

In many ways, Singular Sound’s Midi Maestro checks many boxes. It’s sturdy, has screens for each button, and covers the major functions.

Although the Midi Maestro is really intended for integration with Singular Sounds other products – namely the Beat Buddy and Aeros Loop Studio – it can still function as a reliable MIDI foot controller.

And it is one of the few controllers with Bluetooth capacities. It also has an easy to use app. (Pay attention, other manufacturers!)

The Maestro is more limited than the MC8, Pacer, and SoftStep in most ways, but it has some real pros:

  • sturdy
  • easy to use and program (in part because of limited options)
  • easy-to-read screen for every single button

If you are married to the Beat Buddy and Aeros Loop Studio, then this is a natural fit. But at this price, there’s not a great reason to buy it compared to the MC6 or MC8 or SoftStep2.

However, if that simplicity and great mobile/tablet to foot controller via Blutooth connection is just what you need, then the Maestro is a winner.

Specs

  • Singular Sound Midi Maestro Controller
  • Easy to use MIDI Foot controller; presets for popular gear; easy customization
  • Customizable high visibility screen for each button
  • 10 active pages per preset; sends up to six MIDI commands in a single press
  • Mobile app to set up MIDI enabled devices
  • Daisy chain MIDI Maestro’s together for unlimited control
  • Expression pedal & extension pedal ports; Controls: 0
  • Display: 6 x customizable
  • Footswitches: 6
  • Connections: 5-Pin MIDI In & Out, Expression Pedal (1/4″ TRS-Jack), Extension Pedal (1/4″ TRS-Jack),
  • Power Supply connector: Barrel Connector 5.5 x 2.1 mm, center negative; powered by a 9 V DC Power Supply (included)
  • Dimensions (W x D x H): 213 x 146 x 48 mm (8,38″ x 5,75″ x 1,88″); Weight: 510 g (1,13 lbs)

(Specs from Thomann)

SoftStep2

For some real out of the box thinking, meet Kenneth MacMillan’s SoftStep2. This is a nearly limitless, reported indestructible strip of MIDI magic.

Available from Thomann or Amazon

Every single switch can perform any MIDI function you want, even as an arrow key. Unlike all of the others, these pads are also velocity sensitive (and each can function as an expression pedal).

If you were just to look at functions, the SoftStep2 has the most. You’re spoiled for options, and that comes with a rather steep learning curve.

Or so it seems.

The manufacturers anticipated MIDI-weary users and have made two software editors: a simple one and a pro one. This means that if you want to have rather simple functions – say 6 toggle switches, 2 expression pedals, and 2 program change switches – you can program that rather easily.

And if you want the lights to dim in inverse proportion to the interval of your pitch bend, which also modulates your overdrive…well, you can do that too.

Visually, the SoftStep couldn’t be further from the landing strip-sized, small amp-weighing FCB1010. But it’s just as tough – well, tougher actually.

If you’re looking for the tactile feed back or the click of a sure-footed stomp, you won’t get that here. And really the nuances of the 4-directional pedals (if you use that option) call out for socks more than Frye boots.

I mean, it is called the SoftStep, after all.

Still, there is plenty of room to step and stomp on the SoftStep. While it doesn’t have screens or even color-coding for each pedal, they are enumerated and very clear to read.

Available from Thomann or Amazon

Specs

  • 10 Illuminated cross-shaped, pressure-sensitive buttons
  • Raised rear button row
  • 10 x Two-color LEDs
  • 4-Character LED display
  • Control of controller data by up / down and right / left movement
  • Up to 6 commands per pad: note, CC, pitch bend, program, MMC, HUI or OSC
  • MSB & LSB Pitchbend support
  • Special adaptation to the Kemper Profiling Amp
  • Power supply via USB
  • Class Compliant
  • Robust, stage worthy construction
  • Housing: carbon / fiberglass
  • Graphical interface for programming the hardware
  • Compatible with MAC OS, Windows, Linux, iOS and Android
  • Dimensions (W x D x H): 445 x 107 x 25 mm
  • Weight: 0.54 kg
  • Including Softstep Software Suite

(Specs from Thomann)

Recommendations

You know your needs better than anyone. In light of your musical set up, these are some things to consider.

If you’re looking for some quick on/off messages, the MP-100/MelAudio footswitch will do the job. The FCB1010 is also a good, large, heavy option.

For around double the dough, the Pacer or MC-6 give you a lot more growing room.

For Line6/HX Stomp and other multi-effects units and amps, the FCB1010, Pacer, MC-6/MC-8, or SoftStep2 will do you nicely. That’s a range from around $120-$360.

The Morningstar pedals (MC3, 6, and 8) are outstanding. Their editor is easy to use, and the MC8 in particular performs many functions and has many options that make it well worth its price. For ease of use with Helix/HX pedals like the Stomp, the MC6 and 8 are ideal.

The advantage of Nektar’s Pacer over the MC8 has to do with its size (in some scenarios) and a layout making it more conducive to fast-action stomping. If you’re using supported DAWs and want quick shifting between track, transport, and custom presets, Pacer has real advantages there.

Pacer is missing a factory-designed editor and is painfully overdue for a robust firmware update.

The Rolls Royce in terms of options is Keith McMillen’s SoftStep2, and it’s also the most expensive of the foot controllers reviewed here. Still, it is an incredibly versatile pedal, a great value, and an impressive piece of technology.

For tech geeks, the MC8 and SoftStep2 are about as good as it gets. For improvisers who want a one-pedal-to-rule-them-all, SoftStep’s consolidation is a great strength.

The SoftStep2 does have very limited visual information (no text, no icons), which puts it at odds with the immense diversity of actions you can get from the pedals themselves. If you’re working with a computer screen or have a rather simple setup, it’s no problem. But if you’re on stage and switching batches with different assignments per preset, you might run into trouble.

Wrapping it up

As you see, there is no one pedal to rule them all. But, because of their diversity, there is a pedal that is probably pretty near perfect for you.

So while there are a couple of pedals that seem like clear winners in terms of options, they might not be your best bet if you’re playing with a DAW or needing more visual information.

Be honest about your needs and also your desire to spend time with a new technology. Having a thousand functions doesn’t matter if you only need two.

All of the devices here have good resale value. So if it turns out that your pre-search wasn’t perfect, you can still get most of your money back and go a different direction if you like.

Table of Contents

Before you bounce...

Stay up to date on best deals on the newest gear.
Sign up for our mailing list. 
N